Section: Lesson 2: Argumentation and Reasoning Across Disciplines | Critical and Systems Thinking | NextGenU.org

  • As Dr. Chen delved deeper into the investigation, she found herself at the center of a complex web of interdisciplinary connections. The outbreak seemed to have links to environmental factors, socioeconomic conditions, local industrial practices, and even urban planning decisions made decades ago. Maya organized a series of meetings that brought together environmental scientists, sociologists, industrial hygienists, urban planners, and public health experts. Each group presented compelling arguments from their own field of expertise, using discipline-specific jargon and methodologies. The challenge of synthesizing these diverse perspectives and evaluating the strength of each argument across disciplinary boundaries was daunting. Maya struggled to find a common ground that would allow these experts to communicate effectively and build on each other's insights. She knew she needed to develop a framework for interdisciplinary argumentation to bridge these different fields and get a clearer, holistic picture of the situation.


    If you need extra help along the way or want to practice more, please feel free to use the free Tutor Bot for this course. Before interacting with the Tutor Bot, you must create an account with OpenAI

    Click here to start this lesson

    • Read the entire lesson summary. If you want to explore the topic in more detail, please visit the references at the end of the document.

    • Click on the link to start with this lesson's microlearning component. Microlearning is meant to facilitate active learning; the questions within the microlearning are not graded. Have fun with it! 

    • This document contains more concise notes to help you study or quickly refresh your mind about the content, as well as extra practice questions.

    • This link will take you to the Quizlet platform, where you can flip through the flashcards, test yourself, and even play games to help you learn the content!

    • Click on this link to access the Tutor Bot.

    • This branching logic activity will help you practice and apply what you've learned about the foundations of critical thinking to real life scenarios. 

    • quiz icon
      Quiz: Lesson 2

      To access the quiz, click on the name of the quiz provided above. On the following screen, click the attempt quiz button to view the case studies and respond to the questions.

      TO PASS THIS QUIZ YOU MUST OBTAIN A SCORE OF 80%.

      Not available unless: The activity Quiz: Lesson 1 is marked complete
    • Maya (Dr. Chen) developed a framework for interdisciplinary argumentation, facilitating structured debates among experts from different fields. This approach revealed overlooked connections between industrial practices, urban planning, and ecosystem changes. The team's integrated understanding brought them closer to solving the mystery, demonstrating the power of cross-disciplinary collaboration.